- SEC appeals Ripple case ruling, challenging the decision that XRP is not a security in secondary market sales.
- Attorneys discuss potential cross-appeal, questioning whether institutional XRP sales are true investment contracts.
- Ripple’s ongoing legal fight could reshape crypto regulations and influence token classification in the U.S.
Lawyers Kristi Warner and James Murphy discussed the current developments of the Ripple case, specifically on the SEC’s recent motion. They also considered whether they might be able to file a cross-appeal and what the ramifications of doing so might be for this case and the crypto market.
The Ripple case has dominated much of the news in the cryptocurrency space. Before that, Judge Torres stated that XRP, which is XRP is not a security. This was a big win for Ripple as it meant only the institutional offerings of XRP are securities that were sold without registration while retail offerings were not. Crucially, there was no fraud or loss and the action against platform was a civil penalty only.
Ripple SEC Appeal Expected
James Murphy said that the SEC’s appeal was expected because the agency had once tried to make an interlocutory appeal in the middle of the case, which means that they did not like the ruling. The SEC was not pleased with the court’s ruling, particularly the part that said XRP is not a security; it officially appealed last week, and now everyone is waiting for what will happen next.
Murphy described the process of the SEC appeal, saying that after filing the notice, there are 14 days in which they have to file a detailed form of the matters in dispute. He said the SEC would challenge the ruling that XRP sales on secondary markets were not investment contracts and the court did not require the defendants to give up any gains because nobody had been harmed financially.
Ripple Leaders Respond to SEC Appeal
The Ripple case has garnered much attention and most of the experts have been eager to monitor the hearing of the appeal. Brad Garlinghouse and the Chief Legal Officer, Alderoty have come out to address the actions taken by the SEC.
They pointed out that Ripple might file a cross-appeal, and perhaps question the decision regarding the institutional sales of XRP as securities. Murphy also backs the concept of a cross-appeal stating that the contracts with the institutional investors were not really investment contracts, but rather contracts for the sale of goods similar to commodities.
As the cryptocurrency industry closely monitors the ongoing legal proceedings of Ripple, the future of crypto regulation in the United States and on how tokens are classified, and how agencies are to enforce securities laws in the expanding digital asset market will be determined by the Ripple case.