The long-awaited launch of spot Bitcoin ETFs appears imminent, with multiple providers expected to debut products in early 2024 after years of delays and rejections from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). However, the SEC has dampened excitement by only approving cash-based creations and redemptions rather than the typical in-kind process.
Industry leaders believe this technical requirement will negatively impact the effectiveness of the eagerly anticipated products to some degree. While still representing major progress for Bitcoin adoption, the limitations seem hypocritical given the SEC’s prior allowance of futures-based crypto ETFs, which are criticized as more expensive and complex.
The battle for fully functional Bitcoin ETFs is unlikely to end with the restricted products about to hit the market. Issuers motivated by surging investor demand will likely eventually initiate further legal and regulatory campaigns to permit in-kind creations and redemptions as well.
The core difference between the two models lies in the creation/redemption process. Cash-based ETFs add intermediary steps where the issuer buys or sells the underlying assets separately using investor money. With in-kind ETFs, large financial institutions called Authorized Participants (APs) directly exchange the assets for new ETF shares, avoiding extra complexity.
The Case for In-Kind Bitcoin ETFs
An analysis by BitMEX Research revealed that cash-only ETFs represent just 7.4% of the $11.6 trillion global ETF industry by assets, although they account for 21.7% by number of products. This suggests that most large issuers consciously utilize in-kind creations and redemptions when feasible.
The data also indicated that cash-only ETFs historically have higher tracking errors, meaning they tend to follow benchmark performance less accurately. While the structural differences in Bitcoin markets could lead to different results, the findings contribute to the belief that fully in-kind Bitcoin ETFs would provide superior efficiency and value for investors.
In the end, industry leaders remain confident that the intensifying competition between issuers and surging demand will drive rapid product enhancements following the launch. And despite valid criticisms, the debut of publicly-traded, SEC-approved spot Bitcoin ETFs in the US still represents an undeniably historic leap towards mainstream adoption after years of setbacks.
Most expect eventual resolutions allowing in-kind processes as well. So, while the limitations seem unfair given the prior greenlight for more complex futures ETFs, investors anxiously awaiting exposure through retirement accounts can finally access the crypto-verse through transparent, regulated instruments in just a matter of days or weeks.
Related Reading | SEC May Signal Bitcoin ETFs Launch Decision Next Week: Report