In a recent development, JPMorgan strategists have suggested that the United States Congress could potentially place Ethereum (ETH) into a distinct “other category.” This move aims to avoid classifying the cryptocurrency as a security while ensuring investor protection.
JPMorgan’s remarks followed the publication of the “Hinman documents” earlier this week, which are part of an ongoing legal dispute between Ripple Labs and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).
The strategists propose that Congress might either classify Ethereum alongside Bitcoin in the commodity category or create a new “other category” that imposes less stringent regulations than securities.
According to JPMorgan, this “other category” would offer increased restrictions and investor safeguards compared to commodities but would not be as burdensome as existing requirements for securities.
The comments from JPMorgan come in light of scrutiny faced by the 2018 speech by Bill Hinman, former director of the SEC’s division of corporate finance.
The released documents reveal that certain SEC officials raised concerns about Hinman’s assertion that Ethereum is not a security due to its “sufficiently decentralized” nature.
One comment on the draft speech highlighted that the absence of a “controlling group” in a decentralized network creates a regulatory gap, suggesting the need for some form of regulation to protect purchasers.
SEC Chairman Gary Gensler has recently avoided explicitly stating whether Ethereum is considered a security during a congressional hearing. However, in a previous interview, Gensler indicated that “everything other than Bitcoin” could be classified as a security.
Potential Impact of the “Hinman Documents” On Ethereum & Ripple
JPMorgan strategists speculate that the release of the “Hinman documents” may explain why the SEC has not taken action against Ethereum while targeting other prominent tokens this year.
They believe that these documents will influence the ongoing efforts in Congress to regulate the cryptocurrency industry, potentially leading to Ethereum avoiding classification as a security. Consequently, JPMorgan strategists anticipate a positive impact on Ethereum’s position.
While the release of the documents is expected to benefit Ethereum, JPMorgan notes that it may not directly affect the outcome of the Ripple case.
However, should Ripple succeed in its argument for fair notice, it could have implications for both current and future SEC enforcement actions. Other crypto entities targeted by the SEC could similarly argue that the agency failed to provide them with fair notice.
Related Reading | 1500 Coinbase Users Unite for Amicus Curiae Status in SEC Lawsuit