The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission has requested a federal court to vacate its $5 million settlement with crypto exchange Gemini, arguing that the enforcement case relied on flawed allegations.
The move marks a significant shift in the CFTC settlement case, reflecting changing enforcement priorities under the current U.S. regulatory landscape.
Under a settlement reached with the agency in January 2025, Gemini had agreed to pay a fine of $5 million over accusations of making misleading statements concerning its Bitcoin futures contract.
The regulator now claims the complaint should never have been filed under current enforcement standards. The agency stated that continuing enforcement would not serve the public interest or support its regulatory mission.
Also Read | Solana Hosts SoFi’s 1:1 USD Stablecoin Launch
CFTC Settlement Sparks Major Regulatory Reversal in Gemini Case
The CFTC filing indicates that the original CFTC settlement was based heavily on whistleblower testimony that has since been questioned for credibility.
The regulator also cited statements from Gemini’s former chief operating officer and another individual, alleged to have provided unreliable information, further weakening the foundation of the CFTC settlement.
It was further alleged that the crypto exchange itself suffered losses from customer fraud. According to CFTC, Gemini lost nearly $7.5 million due to fraudulent rebate-fraud schemes by two of its customers exploiting the exchange’s preferential pricing arrangement.
CFTC noted that prior leadership within the agency did not take action, even when faced with admission linked to the fraudulent scheme. The initial lawsuit arose following complaints made in 2022 about Gemini’s misrepresentation of its Bitcoin futures contract.
Regulators had accused the crypto exchange of making misleading statements about volumes in the auction process and liquidity. These factors were considered essential for the evaluation of risk and the approval of the financial product.
Crypto Policy Changes Continue Under Trump Administration
The CFTC’s decision follows broader changes in US crypto oversight since President Trump returned to office. Several lawsuits and investigations by various government agencies involving digital asset companies, so far.
Gemini co-founders Tyler and Cameron Winklevoss previously contributed to Trump’s 2024 campaign, adding further attention to the evolving regulatory environment surrounding the CFTC settlement and broader crypto enforcement strategy.
In the meantime, the current chairman of the agency, Michael Selig, took office following the abandonment of nomination for the same post by Brian Quintenz.
Speculations persist about possible conflicts of interest and political pressure issues at the agency. Currently, there are four vacancies among the five CFTC commissioner positions.
Also Read | Ethereum Price Wobbles Near $2K as Justin Bons Blasts Vitalik Buterin’s ETH Vision
