- Locked token holders saw average drawdowns near 50%, underperforming the broader crypto market’s 40.7% decline.
- Early-stage investors in tokens like SCR, BLAST, and EIGEN faced catastrophic losses, with drawdowns as high as -88%.
- Lock-up periods have become volatility traps, exposing investors to sharp repricing risks amid shifting market sentiment.
Locked token holders have faced an average drawdown of nearly 50% when comparing their current holdings to over-the-counter (OTC) valuations from May 2024. The findings, published by STIX founder Taran Sabharwal on April 22, shed light on the brutal market correction that has disproportionately impacted early-stage investors with illiquid positions.
Sabharwal’s data, which tracks the fully diluted valuations (FDV) of key tokens over the past 12 months, illustrates the steep gap between expectations and reality for crypto holders who participated in early fundraising rounds. The report analyzes notable projects such as JITO, BERA, ZRO, WLD, TIA, IO, W, ZK, EIGEN, SCR, and BLAST, many of which saw their valuations crater compared to their OTC benchmarks.
The worst-hit tokens include SCR and BLAST, which posted catastrophic year-over-year drawdowns of -85% and -88%, respectively. EIGEN wasn’t far behind, with a -75% drop, while ZK, W, IO, and TIA also suffered double-digit percentage losses ranging from -44% to -64%.
Out of the entire list, only JITO defied the trend, registering an impressive +75% gain relative to its OTC valuation from the previous year. It stands as a rare outlier in a landscape marred by bearish momentum and shattered investor confidence.
The Hidden Cost of Early-Stage Crypto Investing
The disparity between OTC valuations and current market prices underscores the inherent risk in early-stage crypto investing, especially when tokens are subject to lock-up periods and vesting schedules. These restrictions, while designed to incentivize long-term alignment, can become a double-edged sword in volatile markets.
“Investors often buy into locked tokens at steep valuations during bullish cycles, but by the time tokens hit the market, the landscape may have changed entirely,” Sabharwal noted in the report. “Many could have exited at double the current price if liquidity had been available a year ago.”
The data suggests that holders of locked tokens may have missed optimal exit points throughout 2024, especially as broader crypto markets also saw a correction. According to Artemis data, the 22 tracked crypto sectors, including bellwethers Bitcoin (BTC) and Ethereum (ETH), experienced an average drawdown of 40.7% during the same timeframe. Though significant, this was nearly 20% better than the average performance of locked token positions.
Hype to Hurt in Early-Stage Crypto Deals
This analysis is a sobering reminder for venture capitalists, angel investors, and retail participants in early-stage token rounds: lock-up periods are not just illiquidity events; they’re volatility traps.
The compressed timelines between fundraising hype and market reality are putting newer projects under intense scrutiny. As secondary markets continue to reprice expectations, FDVs are coming down hard, often leaving early backers in the red long before their tokens are even fully vested.
While the promise of early access and preferential pricing remains alluring, Sabharwal’s data highlights the need for more realistic valuation models and better risk-adjusted strategies in the private token market.
In a space where liquidity is king and narratives shift overnight, the lesson is clear: holding through a lock-up might cost more than the premium investors paid to get in early.
Related | Institutional money flows into XRP, price rises to $2.22 with 47% volume surge
