In a closely followed legal dispute between Ripple and the US SEC, Gene Hoffman, Chief Operating Officer of Chia Network, tweeted on December 6th that he believes the only possible outcome is that a federal judge will rule that XRP was a security due to Ripple’s sale.
The SEC’s messiness in relation to the Hinman speech, he said, is not something he is justifying. He asserts that it is irrelevant to the MSJ/court issue and that the only situation in which it is relevant is when Ripple should have swiftly informed XRP owners of what he had stated.
This prediction was made in a Twitter spat from December 5th, when Gene claimed that Bill Hinman had informed the Ripple leadership that, in his opinion, XRP would be security, in 2019. Some crypto enthusiasts said that it was “completely irrelevant.” Gene claimed that its sales meet the Howey test.
In response, BRAND, the crypto holder and XRP aficionado, said on December 6th:
XRP is currently used for utility moving billions annually. Also, Ripple already settled a lawsuit with Fincen, who labeled XRP as a currency. The SECs can only hope the judge views early sales as security offerings. There is no outcome where XRP the token has deemed a security.
Is Ripple Token XRP A Security?
Famous XRP lawyer Bill Morgan recently argued that the SEC had reached a deadlock on the matter. The first requirement for Howey, according to the attorney, is a monetary commitment, and the second prerequisite is a common enterprise.
Morgan asserts that the SEC has an issue with common enterprises that it has attempted to conceal by defining the term inexactly. SEC also employs a variety of arguments to equate the words “enterprise” with “effort.”
According to the tweet’s comment section:
It relies on broad vertical commonality rejected in the second circuit. Secondly, it cannot prove pooling required under the Revak decision.
The characteristics of a for-profit business venture that Ripple claims are necessary for a common enterprise are not identified by the SEC. In his perspective, the SEC’s inability to differentiate between Ripple’s ODL company and the XRP is an example of how difficult this is for the SEC to do.
Moreover, where everyone is debating Ripple’s lawsuit. Michael Saylor, a prominent supporter of Bitcoin, is infamous for being uninterested in other currencies like Ethereum and XRP. Saylor recently discussed categorizing such coins as securities in a podcast appearance.
Saylor stated his opinion that XRP is an unregistered security in relation to the legal dispute between Ripple Labs and the SEC.
Related Reading | Bitcoin And Ethereum ETFs Filed By Hong Kong’s Three AUMs